Each of the four UK nations has a process for holding Case Reviews where a child dies or is seriously harmed. Each nation has its own guidance and criteria around the process for conducting Case Reviews and around the dissemination of learning. The purpose of Case Reviews is to seek ways to reduce the risk of recurrence of similar incidents by identifying and sharing key lessons and themes, locally as well as nationally.
Common Principles across the four nations:
- In each nation there is a clear criteria and referral process and framework in relation to how a practice review is undertaken.
- Reviews are about learning to improve and embed good practice in the future and not about holding individuals or organisations to account.
- The lessons learned from reviews should be shared with organisations, stakeholders and partners.
- Understanding where there are themes and systemic issues can reduce the risk of the same mistakes occurring again.
- Reviews contain very sensitive including personal information. Significant care needs to be taken to preserve the confidentiality of the subjects and others involved.
Child Safeguarding Practice Reviews (previously referred to as Serious Case Reviews)
In England Working Together to Safeguard Children 2018 requires Local Safeguarding Children’s Partnerships to make arrangements to identify and review serious child safeguarding cases which, in their view, raise issues of importance in relation to their area. They must commission and oversee the review of those cases where they consider it appropriate for a review to be undertaken. The responsibility for exploring how lessons are learnt from serious child safeguarding incidents nationally is held by the Child Safeguarding Practice Review Panel. Their Annual Report 2018-19 can be accessed here
The Department of Education publishes a triennial analysis of Case Reviews in England: which can be accessed here
Research in Practice has developed a range of resources exploring learning from Case Reviews which are accessible here
Child Practice Reviews
In Wales, a Child Practice Review (CPR) should be carried out where a child has died; sustained a potentially life-threatening injury or sustained serious and permanent impairment of health or development. Working Together to Safeguard People: Volume 2: Child Practice Reviews (2019) provides the key guidance for conducting Child Practice Reviews. A Child Practice Review can be either a Concise or Extended Review depending on whether the child involved was on the Child Protection Register or in care six months before the harm occurred. Final reports of Child Practice Reviews must be published by the Safeguarding Children Board and submitted to the Welsh Government. Child Practice Reviews must contain an Action Plan.
- Northern Ireland
Case Management Review
In Northern Ireland, a Case Management Review must be held where a child dies or is significantly harmed when abuse or neglect is suspected, or where a child (or sibling) is in care or has been subject to a Care Protection Plan. The key guidance for conducting a Case Management Review is Learning from Practice - Case Management Review Process Multi-Agency Guidance (Safeguarding Board for Northern Ireland, 2017). 'Learning from practice' case management review process multi-agency guidance (PDF). The Case Management Review (CMR) Panel will, on considering all of the information, decide whether a Practice Review is required and appoint a review team and chair. The Safeguarding Board for Northern Ireland published a learning from Case Management Reviews document (2019). Learning from case management reviews (PDF)
Department of Health, Social Services and Public Safety (2014) Guidance to Safeguarding Board for Northern Ireland (SBNI) (PDF)
Translating Learning into Action: An overview of learning arising from Case Management Reviews in Northern Ireland 2003-2008 (Queens University, NSPCC Northern Ireland and DHSSPSNI) can be accessed here
Significant Case Review
In Scotland, a Significant Case Review is required in cases which raise serious concerns about professional or service involvement and where a child has died and abuse, neglect or suicide is known or suspected to have been involved, or where the child is in care or has been on the Child Protection Register at any time. A Significant Case Review may also be held where a child has suffered or is at risk of significant harm and the case gives rise to concerns about professional involvement. Key guidance around Significant Case Reviews is found in Guidance for Child Protection Committees: conducting a significant case review (Scottish Government, 2015). National guidance for child protection committees: conducting a significant case review (PDF).The Child Protection Committee on considering all information decides whether to initiate a Significant Case Review and appoints a lead reviewer. In 2019 The Care Inspectorate for Scotland published a review of learning from case reviews in Scotland between March 2015 and April 2018 Learning from Significant Case Reviews. Once a Review is complete it is up to the Child Protection Committee to decide whether to publish the full report or just the executive summary.
See also, Scottish Government (2014) National guidance for child protection in Scotland (PDF).
The Care Inspectorate for Scotland has published a review in 2019 of learning from significant case reviews between 2015-18. It can be accessed here
An Interim Review of Scotland’s Child Protection arrangements, “Protecting Scotland's children and young people: it is still everyone's job” was published in 2017 and can be accessed here
The Scottish Government intends to launch a consultation on the draft of revised National Child Protection Guidance. The launch and engagement events have been postponed in light of Covid-19 and The Scottish Government is currently engaging with stakeholders to establish a suitable timeframe for launch of the consultation. Further information is available here
The Association of Independent LSCB Chairs and the NSPCC launched the National Case Review Repository in 2013 where LSCB’s share their published Case Reviews. The Repository is a useful resource in understanding practice failures and lessons learned for practice development.
The NSPCC has some country specific summaries of the Case Review process in each of the four UK nations. It can be accessed here.
A number of Case Reviews which relate to foster care and other family placements have been identified and details are available here.